|
Operational Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
This "Operational FAQ" addresses some of the
common questions and misperceptions about our rescue operations.
If you have a specific question about a technique, method or even a particular
rescue please contact us and we will
attempt to answer to the best of our ability, as time permits. See also
Rescue Operations - How does it all work? (Note that
it is our policy not to discuss specific patient medical information with the public.)
FAQ1: Why do these rescues take so long?
FAQ2: Why do you carry the litter straight downhill instead of using a trail? (Or, what is a “scree evacuation?”)
FAQ3: Why do these rescues require so many rescuers? And why are many of those people just standing around?
FAQ4: Why do the rescuers continue to wear backpacks during the evacuation? Wouldn't it be easier without them?
FAQ5: Why do you use a litter on a vertical evacuation instead of lowering someone with a climbing harness to save time?
FAQ6: Why send the litter across the stream on a high line (Tyrolean traverse)? Why not just walk down the trail to the bridge?
FAQ7: Why did you close the road or my favorite trail?
FAQ8: Does RMRG ever look at other, possibly more efficient, rescue techniques?
FAQ9: Does RMRG ever use actual rescue evacuations as training events?
FAQ10: Will I get charged for rescue?
FAQ11: How can I help?
|
FAQ1: Why do these rescues take so long?
From the time RMRG is dispatched to the time the patient is
delivered to the ambulance, most mountain rescues in Boulder County
are completed in less than two hours. Rescues go faster if access
to the patient is uncomplicated and/or a short distance from a
trailhead. Rescues requiring highly technical litter evacuations
from climbing walls (such as the Redgarden Wall in Eldorado Canyon
State Park) usually take significantly longer due to their complicated,
multi-stage nature (see FAQ3). Establishing patient
location and rescuer access, providing stabilizing medical care, getting
the evacuation gear to the scene, building suitable lowering anchors,
and evacuating the patient(s) all add to the total time to complete
the rescue. RMRG strives to minimize the time required for rescues,
which maximizes both patient and rescuer safety.
Return to top
|
FAQ2: Why do you carry the litter straight downhill instead of using a trail? (Or, what is a “scree evacuation?”)
Evacuating an injured person over rough terrain is hard physical work.
An average-sized patient, plus medical equipment and the litter itself,
usually weighs around 250 lbs. Our standard is to have six litter bearers.
Each rescuer then has to lift and hold around 40 lbs. Walking or moving
quickly down a steep trail while trying to carry a 40 lb load is not difficult
if it is well packaged in a backpack, but it can be quite difficult if
it is part of a 250+ lb load that 5 other people are also carrying.
Foot trails are rarely wider than a single person. A litter is carried with
three rescuers on each side, so the total width of a carried litter is about six feet.
Thus while carrying a litter along a typical trail crossing a hillside, the rescuers'
feet are actually on the loose and much rougher terrain upslope and downslope of the
trail. A litter evacuation following a trail across a hill would have a high risk of
rescuers slipping or dropping the litter-borne patient.
Scree evacuation litter lowering; click to enlarge
Because of the litter and patient weight, the bulkiness of the load, the steep, uneven terrain, and the fact that we are evacuating an injured patient, a belay system that can protect the litter from sliding downhill is imperative. Belaying the litter as it travels along a meandering trail would be prohibitive both in terms of time and logistics. In addition, traversing a trail means following the meandering path of the trail, which often means going up as well as down. Carrying the 250+ lb litter uphill repeatedly would be a needless waste of time and energy.
To overcome this problem, we use a "scree evacuation" technique. A rope is tied to the head-end of the litter which is then lowered and belayed down the fall line. Rescuers lift the litter off the ground and their feet act like the litter's "wheels." With this technique rescuers tension the rope as they hold onto the litter, helping to stabilize the rescuer as he or she walks downhill. The rope takes a large portion of the load and protects the patient and rescuers from falling. The steeper the slope, the more load goes on the rope, and the less weight the litter bearers need to lift. Just like in a standard rappel, staying in the fall line minimizes the potential "pendulum" swing across a slope.
For these reasons, going straight down the fall line is both safer and faster than following narrow, switch-backing trails.
Return to top
|
FAQ3: Why do these rescues require so many rescuers? (And why do many of those people appear to be just standing around?)
Mountain rescue can be a complicated, multi-stage process with many distinct activities. Even when only a scree evacuation (see FAQ2) is required, the logistics of the rescue can be quite involved. Occasionally we need to use up to three different evacuations for the same rescue: a vertical evacuation, a scree evacuation, and a Tyrolean highline.
Some rescuers go into the field fast and light (the "hasty team")
to reach the patient quickly and begin medical care. Subsequently, multiple
rescuers carry gear (e.g. litter, full-body vacuum splint, oxygen, medical
kits, ropes, anchor equipment, litter rigging, brakes/belay devices, etc.)
up to the scene. A vertical evacuation usually requires two litter attendants,
one or two other rescuers to manage medical care and loading the patient
into the litter, and personnel to build and manage an anchor. A scree
evacuation usually requires a six-person litter team, route finders,
brakemen, and rope handlers to implement the belays. A Tyrolean (see
FAQ6) requires a haul team to tension the highline
and personnel to handle tag lines to control the litter as it traverses
the highline. Each distinct phase of the rescue requires one or two
personnel to oversee, plan, and consider overall safety and efficiency
issues. Command personnel manage contact with the rest of the world,
including air ambulance service, the news media, and park visitors.
Consider a climber injured mid-wall. He or she must first be secured,
then medically evaluated and stabilized. A rescue-strength anchor is
built for the evacuation and gear (litter, medical kits, ropes) is either
lowered or raised to the patient's location. Rescue anchors commonly hold
1,000 lbs. (4.5 KN), considerably more than normal loads for recreational
climbing anchors. The patient is then loaded
into the litter – possibly while rescuers and/or the patient are hanging
in a harness. The patient is then lowered down the cliff with two litter
attendants attached to the litter. (In rare cases the litter might be
hauled up, requiring further personnel for a haul team.) From the base
of the cliff, the patient must be evacuated to the nearest road, or
possibly to an air-ambulance (helicopter) landing zone. This often requires
a scree evacuation (see FAQ2) and occasionally a Tyrolean
highline (see FAQ6). Each activity takes multiple rescuers
to complete efficiently and safely. Management of the overall rescue
and of each component is also a critical function and requires additional
personnel in the field and at the trailhead.
While a vertical evacuation can often be done with 5-10 people
Mid-wall loading patient into litter; click to enlarge
(both on the wall and assisting from the ground), a scree evacuation takes many more (see FAQ2). While a full, multi-pitch scree evacuation is possible with only six litter bearers, rotating litter bearers off and on the litter expedites evacuation, improves the patient's ride, and prevents rescuer exhaustion. Personnel are also needed to run brake (belay lowering) stations. Most scree evacuations require multiple pitches (rope lengths). Having personnel distributed down the slope at every brake station can save significant time in the evacuation.
Ideally, rescuers are pre-positioned in critical spots where they can contribute to rescue efforts as the evacuation progresses. In the case of a vertical evacuation that transitions into a scree evacuation, a complement of rescuers will be waiting at the base of the wall and down the scree slope to efficiently transition to the scree evacuation without wasting time. While in theory this entire process could be done with a small handful of people, our experience is that it is quicker and safer to use more rescuers.
In addition to the personnel requirements detailed above, other personnel may be needed depending on the situation. In many of the rescues on Redgarden Wall in Eldorado Canyon State Park, for instance, we fix ropes and haul rescue gear up the East Slabs in case it will be more effective and efficient to lower gear in from above the patient. And since highly-specific location information rarely comes initially, rescuers spotting with binoculars are often necessary to locate the exact location of the accident. For an example of such a mission, see our 27-Apr-08 "Doub-Griffith" rescue page.
Can we sometimes execute missions with fewer people? Absolutely. However, having more people allows us to set up the phases of the evacuation in parallel, so that the evacuation itself goes much faster, thus providing the best care to the patient. Additionally, we need to plan for contingencies, from the very start of the rescue when we don't yet know what will be required for accessing the patient, to late in the rescue when we need to consider the possibility of an unexpected event (e.g. rescuer or bystander injury). Finally, reserve rescuers often start cleaning up earlier stages of the rescue while the rest of the evacuation is still in progress, allowing RMRG to be prepared that much sooner for the next rescue mission. It is not unusual for us to run back-to-back missions, or even three in a day, during our busy season.
Return to top
|
FAQ4: Why do the rescuers continue to wear backpacks during the evacuation? Wouldn't it be easier without them?
Rescuers carry a variety of personal and group gear in their backpacks during rescues, the amount and type of which varies based on the projected time and conditions under which the rescue will take place. During the evacuation, even one that is expected to be relatively short, rescuers may need water, replacement protective gloves, an extra jacket, webbing slings, carabiners, etc. If they carry their backpacks with them then they are likely to be "back in service" as soon as the evacuation is complete, rather than having to backtrack to retrieve personal gear or have other rescuers carry their personal gear down for them. Personal rescuer preparedness also expedites availability for any subsequent rescue responses during or soon after the active rescue.
More importantly, however, the evacuation of an injured patient through a scree field exposes both rescuers and the patient to significant rock fall hazard from the hillside. Because the patient is strapped into the litter and unable to protect themselves, rescuers are trained to shield the patient from any falling rocks that come toward the litter. Rescuers' helmets and backpacks protect their heads, necks, and spines and are their only defense against rock fall. Rescuers will attempt to turn so that their packs are facing uphill to absorb the impact and thus protect both themselves and the patient as much as possible.
Return to top
|
FAQ5: Why do you use a litter on a vertical evacuation instead of lowering someone with a climbing harness to save time?
The nature of the patient's injuries and the logistics of extracting them dictate how we approach "packaging" our patient. Often, injured climbers have been lowered to the ground by their partner (or other climbers) before RMRG arrives. However, if an injured climber is still mid-wall when we arrive at the accident scene, it is likely because their injuries were serious enough that they could not self-rescue. Although time is often critical in these situations, stabilizing the patient's injuries for the rough ride down the wall and to the ambulance may be one of the most critical steps for a positive outcome. For certain serious injuries, it is particularly crucial that we immobilize the patient with a full-body splint to reduce the risk of further injury or even death.
In some cases, however, the best solution may be to simply lower the injured or stuck person to the ground, in which case that is the approach that will be taken. Clearly, mid-wall rescue work is dangerous for both the injured person and rescuers. We therefore always strive to minimize the dangers while doing what is in the best interests of the patient.
Return to top
|
FAQ6: Why send the litter across the stream on a high line (Tyrolean
traverse)? Why not just walk down the trail to the bridge?
In certain circumstances, using a Tyrolean traverse to cross a
creek or gully is the best evacuation route. For instance, all
evacuations that originate on the north side of South Boulder Creek
in Eldorado Canyon (Rincon Wall, Redgarden Wall, West Ridge, Wind
Tower, etc.) must somehow cross the creek. Using the foot bridge
near the Whale's Tail is a preferred exit route when feasible. In
certain situations, such as evacuations from the Wind Tower or Whale's
Tail areas, we do use the bridge. The foot bridge is wide enough to
walk across with a litter and litter team, which is similar in width
to walking three people abreast. For evacuations from other areas, the
footbridge route is either unfeasible, inefficient, slower, more dangerous,
or all of the above.
To evacuate a patient from the Redgarden Wall area west of the
“Lower Ramp,” the patient must first be brought down to South Boulder
Creek by scree evacuation (see FAQ2), then the creek
must be crossed. To reach the foot bridge from the north side of the
creek, rescuers would have to carry the litter-borne patient along the
trail, traversing the hillside. This evacuation route would be difficult
work for the litter bearers, rough on the patient, difficult to effectively
belay, and destructive to the trail and hillside (see FAQ2).
Thus our options are to carry the litter across the stream (wading),
carry the litter to the bridge along the Streamside Trail, or set up a
Tyrolean traverse to lift the litter across the creek with a taut cable
or rope.
Eldorado Canyon, Streamside Trail middle, footbridge lower right; click to enlarge
If the fall line brings us to the creek about a quarter mile
west of the bridge, a trail-carry over the thin and undulating
Streamside Trail would be required. As anybody who has walked the
Streamside Trail knows, this would require carrying the litter up and
downhill, over large obstacles, and through at least one narrow passageway.
All of this is done easily while hiking, but it is an unnecessary
challenge when carrying a litter, especially one loaded with a critically
injured patient. Our better choices then, are to either wade the creek
or use a Tyrolean.
The decision between wading and Tyrolean is generally based upon
current creek level and operational logistics.
On the
27-April-2008 "Doub-Griffith" rescue
we employed a Tyrol crossing, but for the 21-March-2008 rescue of an
injured climber from the base of "Darkness 'til Dawn," we waded the
creek in exactly the same spot.
At the time of the Darkness ‘til
Dawn rescue the water level in South Boulder Creek was significantly
lower than it was during the Doub-Griffith rescue, and the patient
was initially at the base of the cliff rather than mid-wall on the
face. In that case the scree evacuation from the base of the cliff
quickly reached creek side. The time required to set up a Tyrolean
would have delayed the patient evacuation and the alternate method
of wading the creek was available. Had the level of the creek been
higher, a Tyrolean would likely have been used. In the Doub-Griffith
rescue the creek was high and evacuation speed was critical, but there
was still ample time to ready the Tyrol before the litter arrived to
the creek.
Lifting a litter across the creek on a Tyrolean is smooth for
the patient, significantly faster than a trail carry to the bridge
would be, and once the system is in place it is efficient.
Return to top
|
FAQ7: Why did you close the road or my favorite trail?
When the safety of the public is endangered by rescue operations we may ask park rangers to temporarily close a park area, road, or trails. Certain evacuations in Eldorado Canyon State Park, for instance, bring the litter and litter crew down steep, loose scree slopes (see FAQ2). Rock fall danger from the evacuation may pose a hazard to popular, high-traffic trails below the rescue operation. We make every effort to minimize the time that any road or trail is closed to traffic.
Return to top
|
FAQ8: Does RMRG ever look at other, possibly more efficient, rescue techniques?
Continuously.
We experiment with alternative systems on a regular basis, both during
our field trainings and using our test tower. In the last several years we
have evolved our litter patient-packaging system, modified our litter
rigging, and made several other equipment changes. In 2006, after a
couple years of testing, we replaced the kind of
rope we use in our systems, which rippled through virtually all
the other rescue systems and techniques we use.
We also have many opportunities to see and work with systems and
techniques that differ substantially from our own. In the last three
years alone members of RMRG have trained with, or performed rescues
with,
RMRG test tower from above
at least a dozen other mountain rescue teams around Colorado, New Mexico and Utah. We also learn about alternative techniques and equipment from the many fire departments with whom we respond. Members bring back and share these experiences with RMRG, allowing us to incorporate the best equipment and techniques from the entire rescue community.
During our biweekly classroom meetings (public welcome), we thoroughly debrief and critique every mission we perform. The debrief of a single complex mission might take several hours.
RMRG has been providing emergency search and rescue services to the people of Boulder and those who visit the local mountains for over 60 years. We have pioneered many search and rescue techniques over the decades. We are always looking for ways to make things more efficient. Typically members of RMRG volunteer approximately 14,000 hours per year, much of this in training and in research and development activities. The primary goal of our many hours of research and testing efforts is to improve our service to the people we are trying to help.
Return to top
|
FAQ9: Does RMRG ever use actual rescue evacuations as training events?
No. Each year RMRG conducts 30-35 field trainings, and about 20 classroom trainings, totaling approximately 6,000 person-hours per year for training alone. In field trainings we often contrive complex problems for training purposes. As with any skilled activity, from practicing medicine to mountain guiding, training is the foundation of the mountain rescuer's skills. Competent trainees initially participate on actual rescues with close supervision by experienced rescuers. On actual incidents with real patients, rescuer safety followed by quality patient care are our highest priorities. We never delay patient evacuation or overly complicate evacuation systems during operational missions for training purposes.
Return to top
|
FAQ10: Will I get charged for rescue?
Not by RMRG. Rocky Mountain Rescue is an all-volunteer 501(c)(3)
charitable non-profit organization and does not charge for rescue.
We are a member team of the
Mountain Rescue Association (MRA), and we support their
public position
that charging for mountain rescue may delay a call for help.
Medical services provided by an ambulance or air-ambulance are typically
billed to the patient.
Return to top
|
FAQ11: How can I help?
Thanks for asking! We are an all-volunteer organization and are always seeking additional motivated climbers, mountaineers, and other active and skilled outdoors people. RMRG is a 501(c)(3) charitable non-profit cooperation and we typically get about 50% of our $60,000 annual operating budget from donations and grants. Please see our Get Involved page and Fundraising page to find out how you can become a member or support us financially.
Return to top
|
|